This interview with Alexandra Pelosi about her documentary on Republicans during the 2008 is interesting, and I hope to watch it sometime. But, I'm confused by some of her remarks in the interview. She remarks:
Thousands and thousands, hundreds of thousands of people showed up to
see the McCain-Palin ticket. Maybe a dozen people humiliated me -- you
know, embarrassed me and made me feel really unwanted. I don't want to
paint the whole lot of the Republican base as mean-spirited and cruel
and unfriendly. To me it's more interesting to focus on the real
Christian conservatives who didn't agree with anything I had to say but
invited me over for dinner so that we could talk about it.
And, later says:
There are some things that they see that make them uncomfortable. And I
think we have to respect that and understand that. Not say, "Oh,
they're just extremists. Oh, they're just freaks. Oh, they're just
racists." They're not. They just don't agree with us on, like, moral
and cultural and political issues. They don't agree with us on
anything, really.
But, then she admits that it was common for her to hear Republicans make extremist remarks about Obama.
Every day. It was much more common than you'd think. In the heat of an
election, people say some crazy things. And in the case of the
gentleman you're talking about, I have talked to him since then and
this is just the way he sees it. I heard that every single day. It was
much more common than you'd think. And I think that a lot of them were
mimicking things they heard on right-wing radio.
So, what does she do? Edit the film to make GOPers look less extreme.
Right. I'm not naive. I know that I'm going to be criticized for
picking people who say some extreme things. If you take the guy that
says Obama is the antichrist and use him as a sample of the movie, you
have to take one of the 20 other people who say very reasonable things.
You have to take the woman who says we're angry because -- "The
economy. I went home and cried last night because I just lost my 401K."
There are lots of normal people in this movie. I sat in the edit room
for a very long time. I was very fair in terms of the ratio of how many
people I interviewed that said Obama is the antichrist -- put that in
once. "He reminds me of Hitler" -- put that in once. I heard that every
day at every rally. That doesn't mean that everybody who showed up at
that rally felt that way, but just people on the camera. Remember,
who's going to talk to a camera? These are going to be certain kinds of
people.
I mean, my brother-in-law, my next-door neighbor, my
mom's college roommate: These are Republicans who voted for McCain, who
didn't think that Obama is the antichrist, but of course they don't
want to be on camera, because they don't want to be speaking for the
Republican Party. I think it's really irresponsible to focus on the few
crazies that appear in the movie as opposed to the tons of really sane,
normal people that appear in the movie.
Um, if it's not uncommon to here extremist remarks at GOP political conventions, then isn't it irresponsible to make them look less extreme than they really are?
Recent Comments